Question Report, "Report Generated:,""Nov 18, 2022 2:37 PM""" Topic,Webinar ID,Actual Start Time,Actual Duration (minutes),# Question "RDA in Europe 2022,658 3356 9426,""Nov 17, 2022 9:29 AM"", 434, 38" Question Details, #,Question,Asker Name,Asker Email,Answer,Question Time,Answered Time, 1,Is the Subject Heading indexing set of rules you mentioned related to RDA Cataloguing or is a separate project?,Ricardo Santos,'-,live answered,11/17/2022 10:30:27,11/17/2022 10:33:28, 2,Which specialists are present in the group that is developing the AP,Eric van Balkum (Podiumkunst.net),'-,live answered,11/17/2022 10:32:15,11/17/2022 10:33:53, 3,When will German language version of the Toolkit be published?,Thustan Young,'-,live answered,11/17/2022 10:32:23,11/17/2022 10:35:58, 4,Will the absence of DACH policy statements in the Toolkit be compensated by the handbook? Will option level guidance be covered?,Thustan Young,'-,live answered,11/17/2022 10:33:16,11/17/2022 10:37:42, 5,How many people worked on this project? Were they working full time on it?,Deanna White ISSN International Centre,'-,live answered,11/17/2022 10:33:35,11/17/2022 10:39:04, 6,Have you also looked at the format presented by Melissa Parent in March for the format of application profiles?,Meta,'-,live answered,11/17/2022 10:34:38,11/17/2022 10:40:52, 7,Are you creating work entities (for the German domain)?,Eric van Balkum (Podiumkunst.net),'-,We are having some work entities in our authority file esp. for music resources. Work entities will be an important issue in the future esp. for the further cultural communities e.g. performing arts etc.,11/17/2022 10:36:54,11/17/2022 10:48:50, 8,'@Renate: When you speak of work entities (for the German translation) do you find any issues as regards semantics and syntax?,ARJUN,'-,,11/17/2022 10:39:35,, "9,Will the manual allow for legacy policies which do not necessarily correspond to RDA?,Thustan Young,'-,""We tried to adapt the legacy policies so that they are RDA-compliant, where this was not possible, this is marked."",11/17/2022 10:40:15,11/17/2022 10:51:46," 10,Will the training programmes be open to anyone?,Deanna White ISSN International Centre,'-,live answered,11/17/2022 11:06:21,11/17/2022 11:06:38, "11,""To Alan, British Library. will RDA training you intend to carry out some time next year be available to cataloguers from countries like mine where we are still stuck at AACR2?"",Charles Ogendi Nyamache,'-,""From Alan: When the training is available, we will publish details on our website. The training will be available to anyone, but our capacity will be limited. It won’t be specifically tailored to those transitioning from AACR2."",11/17/2022 11:12:54,11/17/2022 11:40:27," 12,Will you use identifiers to represent clustered records?,Deanna White ISSN International Centre,'-,live answered,11/17/2022 11:26:32,11/17/2022 11:35:29, 13,Hannes are you already talking to suppliers that can develop a library management system that can publish linked data? Or do you think your current system will be able to make this change?,Eric van Balkum (Podiumkunst.net),'-,live answered,11/17/2022 11:31:40,11/17/2022 11:35:51, "14,'@Hannes Lowagie: Can you tell us more about the ""validity check"" using XSLT you're doing? How does it work exactly?,Bernhard Schubert,'-,live answered,11/17/2022 11:33:47,11/17/2022 11:37:14," 15,I guess I should have also asked which identifiers will you use for clusters,Deanna White ISSN International Centre,'-,live answered,11/17/2022 11:38:24,11/17/2022 11:39:12, "16,""'@Hannes: Does the issue of granularity, as regards identifiers, crop up when it comes to data representation."",ARJUN,'-,""Hi arjun, we can show all records that have the same identifier in a certain field (for example same work-identifier) in 1 specific result. We only put the common information of all these records (work level) in that record , afterwards the reader can choose to look mere in detail at the records. Does that respond your question"",11/17/2022 11:40:20,11/17/2022 11:50:01," "17,""Thank you, I am well guided and will be on the look out."",Charles Ogendi Nyamache,'-,,11/17/2022 11:45:32,," 18,Are these music work entities the result of clustering? Are they mainly from classical music? Do you collaborate with GEMA or have plans for this?,Eric van Balkum (Podiumkunst.net),'-,The music work entities are coming from the resources we get from legal deposit and are mainly from classical music. We are having no cooperation with GEMA so far.,11/17/2022 11:45:42,11/17/2022 12:01:11, "19,""Sorry, this last question should have been directed to Renate..."",Eric van Balkum (Podiumkunst.net),'-,,11/17/2022 11:50:08,," 20,'@Hannes: Thanks. I hope I can email you if I have any more queries.,ARJUN,'-,,11/17/2022 11:50:47,, 21,'@Roberto: Can I have your email address please?,ARJUN,'-,roberto.gomez@bne.es,11/17/2022 12:07:21,11/17/2022 12:30:55, "22,""'@Heidrun: Does the """"loser model"""" ensures, better, the aspect of granularity as regards the representation of entities?"",ARJUN,'-,live answered,11/17/2022 13:27:29,11/17/2022 13:28:22," 23,'@Heidrun: Granularity means as representation as faithfully as possible.,ARJUN,'-,live answered,11/17/2022 13:28:52,11/17/2022 13:29:13, 24,My apologies for the confusion.,ARJUN,'-,,11/17/2022 13:29:03,, "25,'@Heidrun: Does the concept of entities in the FRBR model needs rethinking in the current digital milieu?,ARJUN,'-,""Well, I think we all know that the FRBR entities don't work equally well for different kinds of material. But I think they are still rather useful and that's one of the reasons why I am unhappy with the need for a work group (because of the way works do multiply in 3R)."",11/17/2022 13:30:30,11/17/2022 13:33:34," "26,""'@Heidrun: Thanks. I fully concur with you. Besides, I think as we see more and more emerging tech concepts coming up, the issue of data representation, particularly with regards to the sematics-syntax problems may surface time and again big-time."",ARJUN,'-,,11/17/2022 13:35:53,," 27,Does treating aggregate expressions like other expressions mean that you also will to use the whole/part of-relations?,Hanne Hørl Hansen,'-,live answered,11/17/2022 13:47:32,11/17/2022 13:56:59, 28,'@Melanie: Can I have your email address please?,ARJUN,'-,live answered,11/17/2022 13:55:08,11/17/2022 13:57:03, 29,'@Roberto: Can I have your email address please?,ARJUN,'-,roberto.gomez@bne.es,11/17/2022 14:57:47,11/17/2022 15:00:06, 30,Thanks.,ARJUN,'-,,11/17/2022 15:01:46,, "31,""Yes, of course. wtcai@fudan.edu.cn"",Wentong,'-,ok!,11/17/2022 15:30:09,11/17/2022 15:32:56," "31,""Yes, of course. wtcai@fudan.edu.cn"",Wentong,'-,ok!,11/17/2022 15:30:09,11/17/2022 15:33:20," 32,sorry i just saw your message,Wentong,'-,,11/17/2022 15:30:30,, "33,""Thank you! actually i don't mean the whole Q&A, since the recording is ongoing. I meant some extra information, like links and twitters that i noticed appeared in the chatbox earlier. I lost the chat history after the break. I got logged out due to internet issues"",Wentong,'-,""From Ann Van Camp (KBR, the Royal Library of Belgium) to Everyone 11:40 AM" Article of Hannes, see https://repository.ifla.org/handle/123456789/1976 page 12: News from Belgium Twitter: @arjun_sanyal "That's all!"",11/17/2022 15:35:12,11/17/2022 15:39:37," "34,'@Bernhard: Are you from the Vienna University Library?,ARJUN,'-,""Arjun, please use the chat for this type of questions :)"",11/17/2022 15:43:37,11/17/2022 15:44:50," 35,'@Liv: My apologies.,ARJUN,'-,No worries :),11/17/2022 15:46:40,11/17/2022 15:47:27, "36,Are the ""group nomes string"" in a way related to the formerly knows as conventional collective titles?,Ricardo Santos,'-,,11/17/2022 15:56:41,," "37,[Question corected (sorry)]: Are the ""group nomens string"" in a way related to the formerly known as conventional collective titles?,Ricardo Santos,'-,""Yes, a “conventional collective title”, without differentiation, is an example of an authorized access point for work group"",11/17/2022 15:57:20,11/17/2022 16:00:27," "38,""We need the plan to be a work for diachronic works, which are considered to be aggregates too. Are there larger outstanding issues then with the modelling of diachronic works?"",Deanna White ISSN International Centre,'-,""Yes, but that would be next year's EURIG topic " "-)"",11/17/2022 16:16:41,11/17/2022 16:21:29,"